In short
- Listen to how a builder talks about your house. Specific answers are a good sign.
- Get a written, itemised quote, not a single figure, and keep the changes in writing too.
- Ask who will actually do the work, whether they are insured, and how disputes are handled.
- Prefer reviews that are checked and verified over ones anyone can post.
Questions to ask on the visit
- What do you think is causing this, and how would you check?
- What will you use, and why that rather than something else?
- Who will be on site day to day, and are they your own people or subcontractors?
- Does this need building regulations approval, planning, a party wall agreement or an engineer? Who arranges it?
- How long will it take, and what could change the price?
- Can I speak to a customer, or see a project, where you did similar work?
What good answers sound like on an older house
A builder who understands period houses will ask questions before giving answers. On damp, they will look outside before talking about the wall: at ground levels against the damp-proof course, gutters, downpipes and air bricks. They will be wary of recommending injection without finding a cause.
On brickwork, they will tell you whether the house was built in lime and say it should be repointed in lime if so. On chimney breasts and openings, they will talk about the engineer, the steel, building control and your neighbour’s side of the wall. On floors, they will mention ventilation underneath.
Vague answers are a warning: “it all needs doing”, “we always use this”, or a price given before they have looked properly. So is pressure to decide on the day, or a discount for signing now.
A proper written quote
Ask for it in writing, and ask which prices are fixed and which are provisional. On an older house some items can only be estimated until they are opened up, and an honest quote says so. A good quote is itemised: each part of the work described and priced, with what is included and excluded, the materials, how long the price holds, and how and when you pay.
Itemised quotes let you compare builders fairly and see where the money goes. Trading Standards advice is to avoid paying large sums up front. Agree stage payments tied to work completed, and put any changes in writing before the work is done.
Some prices cannot be fixed until work starts, for example a roof before the scaffold is up. A good builder will say so in the quote and explain how it will be priced.
Insurance, the team and who does the work
Ask to see the builder’s public liability insurance, and employer’s liability if they employ staff, and check the dates. Ask who will do the work. Some firms win the work then pass it to whoever is free. A long-serving in-house team, with a named person in charge, is easier to hold to a standard.
For skilled trades such as brickwork, ask about training. A bricklayer who served a full apprenticeship has learned the trade over years on real buildings, which shows on older houses where every wall is different. We are proud of ours: Lee Ricketts, who runs the firm, served a five-year apprenticeship and holds the City & Guilds Advanced brickwork qualification.
Reviews you can rely on
Reviews are useful, but some sites let anyone post one. Look for schemes that check the trader and check the reviews. Which? Trusted Traders, for example, runs credit and customer reference checks, has a trading standards professional assess the business, reassesses traders on an ongoing basis including insurance, and moderates every review before it is published.
Read the detail, not just the score. Reviews that describe a similar project to yours, and how problems were handled, tell you more than a row of five stars.
We have been a Which? Trusted Trader since 2014, rated 4.9 from 34 reviews.
How disputes are handled
Ask what happens if something goes wrong. A good builder will have a clear complaints process and put things right. Endorsement schemes add a route beyond that: with Which? Trusted Traders, if a complaint to the trader is not resolved, it can go to an independent dispute resolution service, free to the customer.
Keep the quote, any variations and payments in writing. That protects you and a good builder alike.
